Cooking on a budget. Or, do you buy economy?

I read with interest posts by both Karen at Lavender and Lovage and Ren at Fabulious Food about a cake off. The same recipe, baked in exactly the same way but using ingredients from differently priced supermarkets. The idea came from Vanessa, who posed the question of whether more expensive ingredients make for a better tasting cake. The results were interesting so please do pop over and see which supermarket came in first place, you may be surprised.

We’re on a tight budget. Our weekly grocery shop is usually around £60-£70 but that has to include all the household ‘stuff’as well as food.  It can be hard but we don’t go without. Mainly because a lot of the things that we buy are from the economy ranges.

There used to be quite a large stigma attached to buying the economy, or basic, ranges but that is lessening all the time. Certainly both Morrisons and Tesco have revamped and repackaged their economy ranges, perhaps to step away from that stigma and encourage the already increasing sales.

For ingredients such as flour I see little point in buying anything but economy unless you need one of the speciality ranges. The price difference is really quite significant – 52p for 1.5kg on economy compared to up to £1.99 for branded, often for only 1kg.

And does a more expensive ingredient really make that much difference? Certainly in some cases it does but take digestive biscuits bashed up for a cheesecake base. Does it really matter if you spent 30p on a pack or closer to a pound? I can’t taste any difference and I think even the pickiest of eater would be hard pushed to do the same.

I mainly shop at Sainsbury’s and can vouch for a lot of their range, though I have also found fantastic products in other supermarkets. It is trial and error and of course some items do turn out to be a false economy through either having to use more or just not delivering on taste but on the whole we are satisfied.

Of course shopping and cooking on a budget has more to it than just buying economy or cheaper ranges. Here are my tips to getting the most for your money.

Shop around if you can. I pick up a lot of things from discount stores such as B&M, Home Bargains and Poundland. They all carry branded items and the price differences can be substantial

I tend to bake with Stork or the supermarket equivalent. Unless it’s a recipe that calls for a real butter taste, such as shortbread, then you’re unlikely to notice a difference. Butter is expensive, baking doesn’t have to be.

Check out your local market. I buy my herbs, spices and dried fruit from a fantastic stall at a very much lower price. There’s also an abundance of fruit and veg stalls, all trying to grab your business and offering £1 bowls.

We eat quite a few vegetarian dishes as we prefer to buy less meat but better quality. Again, our local market has some great buys and the farmers market is even better.

One of the few things that I won’t compromise on is eggs. I will only buy free range but the supermarket prices do make me hesitate sometimes, especially as we get through rather a lot each week. However, at the market (again, it really is a great place to pick up some bargains) I can buy a dozen large free range eggs for £1.90.

Use your leftovers. It can be tempting to leave leftovers hanging around in the fridge until you end up throwing them out anyway. Get creative. Turn them into something else. I used up some leftover shepard’s pie to make some rather yummy Hot Water Crust pies. Blitz those last couple of slices of bread in a food processor to make breadcrumbs and pop them in the freezer.

Check those offers. Are you really getting a bargain? Sometimes it’s cheaper to buy two of a smaller size than one larger item even on offer. Would you be better splitting an offer with a friend? And if you have time, check out the reduced section in supermarkets. You can make some substantial savings, especially near closing time, and a lot of things can be chucked in the freezer for another day.

A lot of people find meal planning helps keep them on track, I don’t personally but that’s just me. You can find lots of meal planning inspiration over at Mrs M’s weekly meal planning linky. Michelle from Utterly Scrummy also does a fantastic weekly meal plan post with costs too.

There’s so much more you can do to make the pennies stretch that little bit further. How about you? What works for you? Do you use economy ranges? What do you think?

If you liked this then you might like:

About Sian Reynolds

I'm Sian, mother to a three year old who thinks she’s a teenager and a husband who has issues with cows. Both have insatiable appetites and are rather fond of cake. And chocolate. And cheese. Freelance this and that, coffee drinker, food blogger. I seem to spend most of my time in the kitchen, with one eye on the laptop and the other watching the toddler run around with a colander on her head.

25. April 2012 by Sian Reynolds
Categories: Food Writing, Tips, Tricks and How To's | Tags: , , , | 25 comments

  • http://twitter.com/HappyHomebird Happy Homebird

    I almost always use the economy ranges at the main supermarkets but we tend to do the main bulk of our shopping at Aldi or Lidl. We don’t do one big shop every week as I find I don’t need to as by writing a rough meal plan I  ensure we have most of the items we need for a fortnight. We have worked out where the cheapest places are to buy our bulkier items like dog food and washing powder so I make sure we are organised to ensure as little shopping trips as possible. 
    Our Lidl is on OH’s way home so for any day to day extras and fresh items (milk 6 pint container is 99p!), he pops in. Every few weeks we go to Sainsburys in the evening and buy reduced meat that we then put in the freezer, We’ve had some amazing bargains on joints of meat doing this. Sam x

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      That’s an extremely good price for 6 pints! I think if you can get to the supermarket in the evenings then you’ll find the heavily reduced prices. We’re without a car and live in a village so it’s difficult for us but I’ve had some fab bargains in the reduced sections in the daytime too. I always try and keep a little space in the freezer for the times when I see something reduced that’s far too good an offer to pass by. Thanks for stopping by x 

  • Karen

    Great post! And, just like you, I bake with Stork which is wonderful in cakes especially, and use butter for special occasions. I ALWAYS use leftovers and also grow a lot of my own vegetables and nearly all my own herbs. FAB post, thanks for the mention! Karen

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Thanks Karen! We have pretty much zero space for growing our own, though my parents have a small patch in their garden (the rhubarb in the photo is theirs) but we’re hoping to be allocated an allotment next year so that should help! And be a lot of fun too! 

  • http://twitter.com/PersianLiving Leila J.

    Fab blog! I try to keep the weekly £ down but sometimes it is hard especially when you run out of the household items that cost that little bit more.  Sometimes I go to costco and buy some things in bulk but sometimes it just isn’t possible so places like Aldi and B&M are just fantastic for keeping the food budget low! As for spices and herbs etc, I buy from the Asian markets as I get what I want at excellent prices! Thankyou!

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      I love Aldi. In fact I think their chocolate is some of the best that you can get in the supermarkets, delicious! I also love their 6 fruit and veg for 49p (at least that’s what it was last time I looked). A good point about Costco, buying in bulk can give you huge savings, as long it’s for things that you’ll use. Thanks for stopping by. 

  • http://twitter.com/madamding Mrs M

    Thanks for linking to me. 

    I don’t always buy economy ranges as quite often I shop at Waitrose which doesn’t really have one! I agree with Stork – not because it’s cheaper but because I believe it makes a far superior sponge cake, so much lighter.

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Ah yes, Waitrose have their essential range don’t they? But I can’t say that I’ve noticed it being particularly cheap. I adore Waitrose and would love to shop there but have to keep it to when we have a little spare cash, though I always end up spending more than I had intended! 

  • http://kitchenbitching.co.uk/ Hells Bells

    I have it on good authority (Holly Bell from GBBO) that Mary Berry, Queen of Baking, prefers to use Stork in her cakes rather than butter as it gives a better texture. If it’s good enough for Mary, it’s good enough for me.

    Excellent post. Only just discovered your blog, but I love it.

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Stork is great and I had heard that Mary Berry prefers it, recommendation indeed! I remember my grandmother only baking with stork and her cakes were excellent and sponges were very light.

      Thank you and thanks for stopping by! 

  • Rainie Bish

    Thanks for posting this, Ive found it really interesting and also all the comments aswell. We are also on a very tight budget and mainly pick the cheaper ranges. We have a really large garden and my hubby does grow a fair amount of veg. We also have several fruit trees. All this helps with our weekly food budget and hes loves pottering around the veg plot listening to the radio.

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      There are some really great comments aren’t there! It’s brilliant to see how everyone else does it too. I’d love our own fruit trees, my parents have a damson tree that produces a fairly healthy crop! 

  • http://www.ritacooksitalian.com/ ritacooksitalian

    I use the economy lines along with the expensive ones. There
    are a few things I do not like to compromise on: canned tomatoes, wines and parmesan
    cheese.  My special Italian ingredients
    come from Delicatessen, but I only buy products reasonably priced. I used to
    buy organic vegetables (before the recession crises), I enjoy now growing my
    own vegetables using our community vegetable patch or buying from my local
    shop. Great post!
     

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Thanks Rita. We’re hoping to be allocated an allotment next year so we’ll be able to join in with growing our own which I’m looking forward to (despite not being very green fingered at all!). I buy economy tinned tomatoes if they’re going to be used to bulk something out, otherwise I tend to make my own sauces as I always seem to have a surplus of tomatoes! 

  • mummyinahurry

    Great post. I love the look of the chocolate cake too and the other blogs you linked to. Top tips Sian.

    When I was working in the pre-GFC days, I didn’t really have a food budget, and spent enormous amounts with Ocado buying all organic etc.  Sadly, those days are long since gone, and we now definitely do have a budget. More generous than many I know, but I prioritise good food over almost everything else. I now shop quite strategically at Aldi and Lidl (the quality and prices are excellent) and top up at Sainsbury’s or Waitrose if I am splashing out. We spend about £600 a month for a family of 4, but that is not just for food, it includes all our sundries, toiletries, cleaning stuff, alcohol etc, and I would say for that we live very well. Like you we tend to have a lot more veggie food, but when we get meat its usually waitrose or the butchers, and I do go quite regularly to a local bakers. I do buy economy ranges, adopting the Martin Lewis trade down philosophy. I guess we all have our thing. I have tried the cheaper Aldi flour, and I did feel it made a heavier bread and cake, so I traded up to either branded on offer or Waitrose own label.  I always get free range eggs, although not always organic (btw Aldi do 15 free range for £1.99!!). I am interested in your Stork tip. I am a bit of a butter snob, but I think I may have to set aside my prejudices and give it a go.

    Now off to get the ingredients for that cake. Looks amazing!

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Thanks Natalie! Do give Stork a go, it really is excellent.

      I do think it’s about making cuts where you can and what works for your family. We’d rather have less meat but make sure that it’s good quality when we do have it but I have friends who aren’t that bothered. Also some products we love, others have hated and vice versa.

      I love that price for eggs in Aldi! 

  • http://feedingboys.co.uk/ Katie_bryson

    great post Sian – really good to get some hints and tips. My mum’s a big believer in baking with Stork – she’s very much in the Mary Berry school of thought on most things cooking.
    My top tips are batch cooking, having a week when I eat out of the freezer/storecupboard as much as possible to eat things down, buying things in bulk and freezing them, growing my own fruit/veg where possible, and like you i’m a huge fan of Sainsbury’s Basics range.

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Thanks Katie. We do the eating from the freezer thing too. I have a habit of putting things in there for another day and it gets full rather quickly! That week really does make a difference to the budget. Great tips!

  • http://twitter.com/BangerMashChat Bangers & Mash

    A great post and really useful tips. I have to admit to being obsessed with meal planning – that for me has reduced how much I spend on food, simply by being organised and reducing our food waste. Like you I love to make the most of leftovers, eat meat as a ‘treat’ item, and we’re trying for the first time to properly grow our own vegetables. I’ll happily swap to the economy version on most items, but never meat, fish, eggs or wine!

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Thank you. I know meal planning works for a lot of people but I just can’t seem to get to grips with it! I’ve seen the economy alcohol and I can’t imagine it tastes very nice, though I may be wrong! We don’t drink any more so it’s not an issue for us (and also has an impact on the budget) but when we did I don’t think we would have bought economy options either. 

  • Pingback: Local Lincolnshire - The Spice MarketFishfingers for tea

  • http://twitter.com/RenBehan Ren Behan

    A great post Sian and like Karen’s and mine, generated some interesting points and discussions. I recently decided to venture across town to shop at Morrisons, which happens to be lovely as they have had a huge refurb and now have a fresh produce market an deven a chef demo. I was astonished at how much I managed to buy for less than my usual weekly shop at Sainsbury’s. Worth travelling a bit further to get those better deals. Lots of useful tips in this post, thank you.  

    • http://fishfingersfortea.co.uk/ Fishfingers for tea

      Thanks Ren. It’s been really interesting to see everyone else’s tips too. I often pop into Morrisons on a Saturday and they have some fab offers. I think they are a little cheaper overall but their lack of online shopping lets them down. If they offered that then I’d be more than happy to do most of my shopping there! 

  • Pingback: Sweet potato chips. Or fries if you're outside of the UK

  • Pingback: Budget cooking: Feeding your family for £50 a week